Top view of someone holding an phone next to laptop

Web Design & Development Insights

7 Tips On Redesigning Your Website Without Losing SEO

Sometimes it makes perfect sense to redesign your website. The goal is to do it as smoothly as possible and not lose SEO ranking and search engine traffic along the way.

7 Tips On Redesigning Your Website Without Losing SEO

Each redesign is unique and requires its own specific process. However, keeping these 7 tips in mind will make it easier for you to redesign your website without losing SEO ranking. At the end there’s a short checklist for the week before and the weeks after launch, using the actual Google Search Console reports you’ll need.

1. Analyze all website pages

Use Google Analytics (GA4) and Google Search Console to see what pages of your website are ranked the highest and which ones are visited the most. In Search Console, the Performance report has a Pages tab that lists your URLs by clicks and impressions from Google. The Links report shows your Top linked pages, meaning the pages other sites link to. Those are the URLs you can least afford to break.

Center the move around them as those pages should get the shortest, typeable URLs that are easy to remember and share (and don’t forget to set up a 301 redirect, more on that later).

And maybe some of these pages should be featured in prime spots in the newly redesigned navigation panel to get even better traction?

2. Rewrite or combine pages that don’t perform well

Look at the rest of the pages that didn’t make it to the top. See if they can be adjusted in some way to yield better results. Sometimes it’s simply a matter of writing a more engaging copy or switching up the featured image.

Rewriting some copy would also fit right along with the redesign itself, so this shouldn’t be overlooked.

3. Don’t erase any pages and use 301 redirects to permanently redirect renamed pages

Simply deleting pages will create 404 “Page Not Found” errors that will negatively affect rankings and the search engine traffic because your site would be essentially getting smaller and throwing away content.

If the specific content is old or irrelevant, you would want to tell Google that there’s a newer version of this content and redirect Google (and of course, your visitors!) to the new page. That way, if the page had good rankings or it was linked to from other sites, you wouldn’t lose that value, since you’re trying to keep your SEO rankings intact.

But even not-so-hot pages are a part of the internal architecture that contributes to spreading link equity. So use 301 permanent redirects to lead visitors to the new URLs while also preserving the SEO ranks of the old URLs. If you need a refresher on how they work, we have a whole post on what 301 redirects are and how to set them up.

One exception: if a page really has no replacement on the new site, don’t point it at the homepage just to avoid a 404. Google’s site move guidance says removed content with no new counterpart should return a 404 or 410, and warns against redirecting lots of unrelated URLs to a single page. Redirect to the closest relevant page, or let it 404.

4. Keep an eye out for 404 errors

A spike in 404 errors is an extremely undesirable outcome of a website redesign process. First, it makes for horrible user experience since site visitors can’t find what they’re looking for (even though Google suggested it in the search results).

This could lead to many users clicking off your page and switching to a competitor.

You can still lower your bounce rate by creating a custom 404 page featuring your most visited pages and including a few words of apology and maybe a nice offer to keep the customer on your website a little longer. We go into more detail on that in things you don't normally consider when redesigning your website.

By the way, a deleted page that isn’t redirected loses its own rankings and any links pointing to it. Make sure that all old URLs receive appropriate redirects! After that, check two places regularly to see if anything has slipped through the cracks:

  • In Search Console, open the Page indexing report and look at the Not found (404) reason.
  • In GA4, look at the Pages and screens report and filter by your 404 page’s title. That shows the 404s real visitors are landing on, which can include old URLs from emails, social posts, or other sites that Google doesn’t report.

5. Check for redirect chains and loops

These are two different problems.

A redirect chain is when one URL redirects to another, which redirects to another, and so on: A goes to B, B goes to C. The page still loads in the end, but every extra hop is another round trip for the browser, so it’s slower. Chains are very common after a redesign, because the old redirects from a previous redesign are still in place and the new ones get stacked on top of them.

A redirect loop is when the redirects lead back to where they started: A goes to B, B goes back to A. The page never loads. The browser gives up and shows an error (Chrome calls it ERR_TOO_MANY_REDIRECTS). As with 404 errors, that will immediately hurt your bounce rate, and Google can’t index a page that never resolves.

Both have SEO consequences. Google’s crawlers generally follow up to 10 redirect hops, so a long enough chain can stop Google from reaching the final page at all. In Search Console, the Page indexing report groups chains that are too long and loops under the same reason, Redirect error.

How to fix them:

  • Chains: update each old redirect so it points straight to the final URL. Google recommends redirecting to the final destination directly.
  • Loops: find the two rules that point at each other and remove or change one. Loops often come from a CMS redirect and a server or plugin redirect that disagree, for example one forcing a trailing slash and the other removing it.
  • Test a sample of old URLs after launch with the URL Inspection tool in Search Console, or run a crawler’s redirect report over your whole URL list.

It is quite common to forget to update the internal links on the pages of your website.

It’s easy to remember to update your main navigation, but you may have a blog with many articles that have links in the content.

This mistake can cost you a drop in SEO rankings as the process of how the search crawler indexes your website is changed.

Of course, redirects could work, but it would be better to update it directly instead. Best case scenario, it’ll create an unnecessary chain of redirects that affects the page load speed.

Worst case scenario, broken links will lead to a 404 error. Make sure that the internal architecture of the website is intact and the changes don’t reduce the search engine’s ability to crawl the website.

7. Monitor the changes

It is extremely important to pay attention to Search Console and your analytics once the redesign is complete. Make sure to submit the new sitemap of the redesigned website and see if it gets indexed properly. Also, pay attention to the data as visitors search for modified content and adjust to the changes.

A redesign SEO checklist: before and after launch

Before launch

  • Save the full list of old URLs before anything changes (sitemap, CMS export, Search Console Performance and Links reports, a crawl). It’s much harder to rebuild once the old site is gone.
  • Map every old URL to its new URL in a spreadsheet. Mark the ones with no replacement as intentional 404s.
  • Set up 301 redirects from that map, pointing straight to the final URLs, and update any older redirects that would now create chains.
  • Check that each new page has a canonical tag pointing to itself.
  • Remove any "noindex" tags or robots.txt blocks that were used on the staging site. This one gets missed a lot.

Launch week

  • Spot-check your most important old URLs. Each should land on the right new page in one hop.
  • Inspect your key new URLs with the URL Inspection tool in Search Console to confirm Google can fetch them.
  • Submit the new XML sitemap in the Sitemaps report. Keeping the old sitemap in there for a while is fine, and Search Console warnings about its redirects are expected.
  • If the domain itself changed (not just the design or URLs), use the Change of Address tool in Search Console. It isn’t needed when you stay on the same domain or only move from http to https.

The weeks after

  • Check the Page indexing report weekly for Not found (404), Redirect error, and Soft 404.
  • Compare clicks and impressions for your top pages in the Performance report against the weeks before launch.
  • Keep the redirects in place for at least a year. Google recommends that so all the signals carry over to the new URLs.
  • Don’t panic over early dips. Google says that for small and medium sites it can take a few weeks or more for new URLs to replace the old ones.

Redesigning a website can be a challenge for a business. It is a unique complex process that depends entirely on the business needs and the initial issues with the original website. Especially if it’s a large website with a lot of content, the redesign has to be done properly to make no harm to the existing rankings and improve website SEO long-term. Hire a web design agency to make sure that the process goes smoothly and you don’t lose any of the rankings that took so much time and effort to build.

Wondering what shape your own site is in?

Get a free 27-point Website Health Check - security, speed, accessibility and SEO. Plain English, no pitch.

Check my site

More to read

Image for Things you don't normally consider when redesigning your website, but should

Things you don't normally consider when redesigning your website, but should

There are a lot of reasons to come to a decision to redesign your website. And while there’s a common culprit of why businesses redesign their websites, there are a few more reasons and ways to approach this process.

Continue reading
Image for How Much Should Website Maintenance Cost?

How Much Should Website Maintenance Cost?

"How much should this cost?" is the right question, and almost nobody answers it honestly. Here's the real range, what separates a $49 plan from a $300 one, and how to work out which one you actually need.

Continue reading
Image for Success is in the details: What makes a website stand out

Success is in the details: What makes a website stand out

Details are everything. They’re those things that can be done to improve any situation and make things more enjoyable.

Continue reading

Let's keep in touch

* We won't spam you or give your email to anyone.

Signup for Shopify Free Trial Try for Free