Choosing A Theme For Your Shopify Store
Your Shopify store needs to have a theme in order to display its product listings and all other information. Learn how to search and choose the right one for your business.
The way your store looks has a lot to do with whether people trust it enough to buy. In a Stanford study, nearly half of the people judged a website's credibility partly on its design. A good Shopify theme gets you most of the way there quickly, so you can spend your time on products and marketing instead of layout.
Every new Shopify store comes with a free default theme already installed. It works, but it's the same starting point everyone else gets. This post is about picking the theme you'll actually run your business on: where to look, how to test before you pay, and what to check that the demo store won't show you.
If you've already picked one, skip ahead to how to customize your Shopify theme.
Where can I get a Shopify theme?
There are three places, and they come with very different levels of risk.
- The Shopify Theme Store. Free themes are made by Shopify, and Shopify support helps you customize them. Paid themes are made by independent theme studios and are a one-time purchase, currently about $100 to $500. A paid theme is licensed to one store, and the sale is final.
- Third-party marketplaces and theme studios. Bigger selection and often cheaper, but these themes didn't go through Shopify's review, and support and updates depend entirely on the seller.
- A custom theme. Designed and built for your store only. More on that below and in pre-made, semi-custom or custom: which one fits your store.
Shopify Theme Store
For most stores, this is the place to start. You can browse the Theme Store by industry, catalog size and features, and every theme has a demo store you can click through.

The bigger advantage is the review process. To get listed, a theme has to pass Shopify's code review, and it has to meet minimum scores for speed and accessibility. Shopify tests every submitted theme on a benchmark store and requires an average Lighthouse performance score of at least 60 and an accessibility score of at least 90. Theme developers also have to keep their themes working as Shopify adds features.
That's a floor, not a guarantee. A demo store has a handful of perfectly sized product photos and no apps. Your store won't look like that, which is why testing with your own products matters.
Free or paid: what's the real difference?
Shopify's free themes are well built and fast. Plenty of successful stores run on them. What you usually get from a paid theme is more built-in features, more layout options and presets for a specific kind of store, and a support team that knows that theme well.
What you don't automatically get is a better store. A $400 theme with features you'll never use isn't an upgrade. Start by writing down what your store actually needs, and only pay for a theme that covers more of that list.
How do I test a Shopify theme before I buy it?
Shopify lets you try any paid Theme Store theme in your own admin for free. Open the theme in the Theme Store and click Try theme. It's added to your themes with a "Theme trial" label, and you can customize it as much as you like. You can have up to 19 paid themes on trial at the same time, and if you buy one, the customizations you made during the trial are kept.
So don't judge a theme from its demo. Put your own store into it and check:
- Your longest product title and your product with the most variants. Does the page still look clean?
- Your real photos. If your images are a different shape than the demo's, some layouts fall apart.
- A collection with many products. Are filtering and sorting easy to use?
- Your phone. Most of your visitors will see the mobile version. Go from the home page to checkout on an actual phone, not just a narrow browser window.
- Speed. Run the theme preview through PageSpeed Insights. A theme that's already slow with almost no content will get slower once you add apps. Our post on speeding up a Shopify store covers what else affects this.
- The apps you already rely on. Reviews, subscriptions, wishlists. Make sure they show up where you want them.
Also look at the theme's reviews, especially the recent ones, and at when it was last updated. A theme that hasn't been updated in a long time can fall behind new Shopify features.
Which features should my theme have?
It depends on what you sell, but these are the ones we see store owners look for most:
- Product filtering and a mega menu, if you have a large catalog
- A long, story-style product page, if you sell one or a few products
- A side cart that slides in, instead of sending people to a separate cart page
- Related products and recently viewed products
- Video on product pages and other pages
- A ready-made FAQ section
- Color swatches on collection pages
Some theme features can replace apps you would otherwise pay for every month, so it's worth comparing a theme's built-in features against your current app list. You can browse apps in the Shopify App Store.
Third-party sites and developers
If nothing in the Theme Store fits your brand, independent marketplaces and theme studios have a wider range of styles. Many have live demos, reviews and a list of features.
Before you buy one, check three things:
- Updates. Theme Store themes notify you in your admin when a new version is out. Outside themes usually mean downloading a new ZIP file and moving your settings over yourself.
- Support. How long is it included, and does it cover only bugs or also help with setup?
- Code quality. Nobody at Shopify reviewed this theme. Test its speed and accessibility the same way you would test a Theme Store theme, or have a developer look at it.
What if my theme is missing something?
No theme does everything. When yours doesn't have a layout you need, you usually have three options: an app, a ready-made section added to the theme, or custom code.
Sections are often the lightest way to do it. Abra Sections are pre-built content blocks you add to your existing theme, so you get a more custom look without changing themes or paying for a full build.
Should I build a custom theme instead?
If you want a store that nobody else has, and features your business needs that no theme offers, a custom theme can be the right choice. A designer and developer build it around your products and your brand, and the code only includes what you use, which helps keep the store fast.
It costs more and takes longer, and you'll be responsible for updates that a theme developer would otherwise handle. We wrote a separate post on the difference between custom and theme-based websites if you're weighing that.
Can I change my Shopify theme later?
Yes. Your products, collections, pages and files stay where they are when you change themes. Only the way they're displayed changes.
What doesn't come with you is anything you set up inside the old theme: section layouts, theme settings and any code edits. Apps that you added with app blocks need to be added again in the new theme. Give yourself time to rebuild your key pages and test them before you publish.
Abra has built Shopify stores on purchased themes, on semi-custom themes and from scratch. If you'd like help picking the right starting point, reach out today and we'll take a look at your store.
Wondering what shape your own site is in?
Get a free 27-point Website Health Check - security, speed, accessibility and SEO. Plain English, no pitch.
Check my site


