Shopify Themes or Building a Custom Theme?
Let's explore the pros and cons of using pre-made themes, creating a semi-custom theme by customizing a pre-made theme, or building a custom theme from scratch when building Shopify websites.
When you build a Shopify store, the design can start from one of three places: a pre-made theme, a pre-made theme that's been changed to fit your brand (a semi-custom theme), or a custom theme built from scratch. The right one depends on your budget, how soon you need to launch and how much your store has to do that a normal store doesn't.
We build all three for clients, and most stores don't need the most expensive option. This post covers what each one really costs, what you give up, and the signs that it's time to move up a level. If you're comparing platforms in general, not just Shopify, read custom vs theme-based websites instead.
Pre-made Shopify themes
A pre-made theme is one you install from the Shopify Theme Store or another marketplace and set up yourself. There's a large selection of themes, both free and paid.
What you get
- Low cost. Shopify's own themes are free. Paid Theme Store themes are a one-time purchase, currently about $100 to $500, licensed to one store.
- A fast launch. The design is done. With your products, photos and copy ready, you can launch in days.
- Things that already work. Theme Store themes pass Shopify's code review and minimum speed and accessibility scores. Common features like filtering, a side cart and quick add are often built in.
- Updates and support. Shopify supports its free themes, and paid theme developers maintain theirs. When Shopify adds a feature, a maintained theme usually picks it up in an update.
- Room to adjust. You can customize your theme in the theme editor, and extend it with pre-built sections when the theme's own sections don't cover a layout you need.
What you give up
- Uniqueness. Thousands of other stores can use the same theme. Different photos and colors help, but the structure is the same.
- Control. You're limited to what the theme's settings allow. Going beyond that means editing code, and code edits don't carry over when you update the theme.
- Some extra weight. Themes are built for many kinds of stores, so they include features you'll never use. It's usually a small cost, but it adds up with apps on top.
Semi-custom Shopify themes
A semi-custom theme starts with a pre-made theme and changes it: a different look, a few custom sections, maybe a product page built around how your customers actually shop. For a lot of growing stores, this is the best value.
What you get
- A store that looks like your brand, not like the theme demo.
- A lower price than a full build. The theme already handles the basics (cart, search, account pages, filtering), so you only pay for what's different.
- A faster timeline than custom, because a designer and developer are adjusting something that already works rather than starting from nothing.
- A solid base. You start from code that has already been tested on thousands of stores.
What to watch
- You'll usually need a designer or developer, unless you know Liquid and CSS.
- How the customization is done matters. Work done through new sections and theme settings survives theme updates. Edits made directly to the theme's own files have to be redone every time the theme updates, and the theme developer's support won't cover them.
Custom Shopify themes
A custom theme is designed and built for your store only. It still runs on Shopify, uses Shopify's checkout and works with Shopify apps, but every page layout and feature is made for your business. If you want the longer list of reasons to go this way, see 7 benefits of custom development for Shopify.
What you get
- A design nobody else has, which matters most in crowded markets where brand is a big part of why people buy.
- Features built for how you sell. Product builders, complex bundles, wholesale and retail in one store, integrations with your other systems. If third-party sections and apps can't do it, custom code can.
- Lean code. Only what your store uses, which makes it easier to keep fast.
- Full control over every change, with no theme developer's update schedule to work around.
What it costs you
- Money. A custom Shopify theme can cost anywhere from tens of thousands of dollars to $100K and more, depending on the design and functionality.
- Time. Expect several weeks to several months from design to launch.
- Ongoing maintenance. Nobody else updates your theme. When Shopify changes something, your developer adapts it. Budget for that from the start.
How do I decide?
Here's how we usually think about it with clients:
- New store, small budget, want to launch soon: a pre-made theme. Spend the money on photos and marketing, and learn what your customers respond to.
- Selling well, but the store looks like everybody else's: a semi-custom theme. Keep the solid base and change what customers see.
- Your store has to do something unusual, or the brand is the product: a custom theme.
Signs you've outgrown your pre-made theme
Most stores don't need to decide on day one. Start with a theme and watch for these:
- You've installed apps to fill gaps in the theme, and the store has gotten slower.
- You're afraid to update the theme because of code changes someone made in the past.
- You keep explaining to customers how to do something the store should make obvious.
- You've seen your exact layout on a competitor's store.
- There's a feature you need, and every app that does it is a workaround.
Two or more of those usually means it's time for a semi-custom or custom project.
Who builds it?
You can set up a pre-made theme yourself. For semi-custom and custom work, you'll need a designer and a developer who know Shopify well. Ask to see Shopify stores they've built, and ask how they handle theme updates and maintenance after launch. If you'd like to work with a Shopify developer, that's what we do.
Not sure which option fits your store? Reach out to us, and we'll give you an honest answer, even if it's the cheapest one.
Wondering what shape your own site is in?
Get a free 27-point Website Health Check - security, speed, accessibility and SEO. Plain English, no pitch.
Check my site


